Media Center

WISCONSIN COURT OF APPEALS REINSTATES IDENTITY THEFT CHARGE AGAINST CHRISTOPHER BARON

 

MADISON - The Wisconsin Court of Appeals issued a decision today reversing a ruling by the Jefferson County Circuit Court that dismissed an identity theft charge against a former City of Jefferson EMS technician. The court's ruling allows the Jefferson County District Attorney to proceed with identity theft charges against Christopher Baron.

 

According to the criminal complaint, Christopher Baron hacked into the work computer of his boss, Emergency Medical Services Director Mark Fisher, and sent several e-mails that he found in Mr. Fisher's e-mail account to about ten people. The forwarded e-mails appeared to have come from Mr. Fisher and suggested that Mr. Fisher was using an apartment owned by the EMS Department to conduct an extramarital affair. The day after Baron sent those e-mails, Mr. Fisher committed suicide.

 

Wisconsin law criminalizes the unauthorized use of an individual's personal identifying information or documents to obtain credit, money, goods, services, employment, or any other thing of value or benefit; to avoid civil or criminal process or penalty; or to harm the reputation, property, person, or estate of the individual whose identity has been used. Baron was charged with six criminal counts, including a charge of identity theft that alleges that Baron used Mr. Fisher's identity without Mr. Fisher's consent with the intent to harm Mr. Fisher's reputation. Baron moved to dismiss that charge, arguing that he had a First Amendment right to disseminate truthful information about a public official, even if his intent was to harm that official's reputation. The trial court agreed with Baron's argument and dismissed the identity theft charge.

 

The Court of Appeals reversed that ruling, adopting arguments made by the Wisconsin Department of Justice. The court held that "the identity theft statute does not criminalize the act of defaming a public official, and therefore does not violate Baron's First Amendment rights." The court noted that the identity theft statute "neither prohibited Baron from disseminating information about Fisher nor prevented the public from receiving that information." "Instead," the court held, "the statute prohibited Baron from purporting to be Fisher when he sent the emails."

 

Attorney General J.B. Van Hollen, whose office handled the appeal, praised the Court of Appeals' decision. "Citizens have a fundamental constitutional right to criticize public officials, so long as they do not disseminate information they know to be false or act with reckless disregard to the truth," Van Hollen said when the state filed its brief last September. "There is no constitutional right, however, to damage someone's reputation by assuming that person's identity without their consent. Wisconsin's laws protect all individuals against identity theft, not by limiting expression, but by prohibiting conduct."

 

A copy of today's decision can be accessed at:

 

http://wicourts.gov/ca/opinion/DisplayDocument.pdf?content=pdf&seqNo=32844

 

This is a pretrial appeal. Baron enjoys a presumption of innocence, and the State will be required to prove his guilt beyond a reasonable doubt at trial.

 

Jefferson County District Attorney David Wambach is the prosecutor handling the case. The State of Wisconsin was represented in the Court of Appeals by Assistant Attorney General Jeffrey Kassel.